10 Mistakes to Avoid When Hiring a Social Media Manager

Avoid common hiring mistakes and find a social media manager who builds trust and delivers long-term results.

Hiring a social media manager should make your marketing more effective, not simply take posting off your to-do list. Unfortunately, many business owners approach the hiring process with the wrong priorities.

They’re impressed by someone’s personal Instagram following, assume a younger employee can handle social media, or choose the cheapest option without understanding what’s involved.

The result? Inconsistent content, missed opportunities, and social media accounts that don’t meaningfully support the business.

At The Seedless Agency, we’ve worked with businesses across different industries and seen firsthand how these decisions can affect results.

The biggest mistake businesses make when hiring a social media manager is confusing the ability to create content with the ability to market a business.

Here are the most common mistakes we see and how to avoid them.

1. Hiring Someone Without Marketing Experience

You wouldn’t hire someone with no marketing background to manage your advertising budget. So why would you hire someone without marketing experience to represent your business on social media?

Knowing how to edit videos, create attractive graphics, or use Instagram doesn’t automatically make someone a qualified social media manager.

A good social media manager should understand your ideal customers, business objectives, competitive positioning, and how to develop messaging that resonates with your audience.

Don’t Be Impressed by Someone’s Personal Following

One of the biggest mistakes is assuming someone who has built a large personal following can achieve similar results for your business.

A lifestyle creator sharing restaurant visits and entertaining videos has a very different challenge than someone managing social media for an accounting firm, plumbing company, or B2B business.

Service-based businesses often require more creativity because their products and services aren’t naturally visually exciting.

A strong personal following demonstrates content creation ability, not necessarily business marketing expertise.

Instead, ask to see business accounts they’ve managed and how their strategies differed based on each company’s audience and objectives.

For more guidance, read our 9 questions to ask before hiring a social media manager.

2. Assuming an Existing Employee Can Handle Social Media

Another common mistake is assigning social media to an employee who already has full-time responsibilities.

Business owners sometimes assume posting doesn’t take much time, so someone on staff can simply add it to their workload.

But social media management involves much more than posting. It requires research, strategy, planning, content creation, scheduling, reporting, and sometimes community management.

A Real Example: When Internal Social Media Management Didn’t Work

We worked with a client who wanted more social media content than their budget allowed under their existing package.

They decided to have an employee handle a few additional posts each week.

Initially, the employee was enthusiastic and had some creative TikTok ideas. But after approximately three weeks, the posts became an afterthought. The employee had other responsibilities, and maintaining even a light posting schedule wasn’t sustainable.

The client realized that knowing how to post and having a few good ideas didn’t replace marketing experience or the capacity to execute consistently.

They eventually increased their social media management package with us.

By maintaining a consistent strategy focused on relationships and community engagement, we helped build a warm, engaged audience that became particularly valuable during the client’s seasonal sales.

The lesson? Consistency requires dedicated time, planning, and accountability. Don’t underestimate the work involved.

3. Making Going Viral a Goal

If a social media manager promises to make your business go viral, consider that a warning sign.

And if you’re hiring someone specifically because you want viral content, you may be focusing on the wrong objective.

Going viral can generate impressive numbers, but those numbers don’t necessarily translate into business results.

Imagine a San Antonio plumbing company gaining thousands of followers nationwide after a funny video goes viral.

Most of those followers may never need its services. If they don’t engage with future content, the account could experience weaker engagement rates and less favorable distribution signals.

I’d rather see a business build a smaller audience of people who are genuinely interested in its products or services.

Focus on Relationships Instead of Virality

A good social media manager should explain that organic social media is primarily about building awareness, trust, relationships, and community.

Those connections can eventually support sales, but chasing viral moments shouldn’t replace a long-term strategy.

If you’re unsure whether your current approach is working, consider whether it’s time to shift your social media strategy.

4. Treating Social Media Primarily as a Sales Tool

One of the fastest ways to turn people away from your social media is to constantly ask them to buy something.

Business owners naturally want sales, but social media audiences don’t follow businesses just to see advertisements.

They want useful information, entertainment, inspiration, expertise, and authentic connections.

How Much Content Should Be Promotional?

My recommendation is that at least 75% of your organic social media content should not be directly sales-driven.

That doesn’t mean you can’t promote your products or services. It means promotional content should be balanced with posts that provide value.

For example, a home services company might share:

  • Helpful maintenance tips
  • Videos answering common customer questions
  • Behind-the-scenes footage of employees
  • Customer reviews and testimonials
  • Explanations of common problems and solutions


When a seasonal promotion comes around, you’re communicating with people who already know and trust your business.

A social media manager who proposes filling most of your calendar with promotional graphics may be trying to satisfy your desire for immediate sales rather than building a sustainable audience.

5. Choosing Based on Price or Post Count Alone

Comparing social media management proposals based solely on monthly fees or the number of posts is a mistake.

Two managers might offer eight posts per month, but the services behind those posts could be completely different.

One might use stock photography and generic captions. Another might conduct research, capture original video, develop custom graphics, and create content around specific marketing objectives.

Those aren’t equivalent services.

Understand What You’re Actually Paying For

Before comparing proposals, ask:

  • Is strategy development included?
  • Will they capture original photos and videos?
  • Are graphics and videos customized to your brand?
  • Is community management included?
  • Will you receive monthly reporting?
  • How often will you meet?
  • Are paid advertising services included?

Another common mistake is assuming Meta Ads or TikTok advertising is included in organic social media management.

If paid advertising is included, clarify whether the actual advertising budget is separate from the management fee.

And don’t assume that requiring payment at the beginning of each month is a red flag. Upfront monthly payment is a common business practice.

Understanding how much it costs to hire a social media manager can help you evaluate the differences between service levels.

6. Hiring Someone Who Doesn't Prioritize Video

If a social media manager plans to use only stock photos and graphics, we’d consider that a significant red flag.

Video is a critical part of modern social media marketing.

That doesn’t mean your business needs expensive production or highly edited videos.

In fact, authentic, minimally edited footage can be more effective at building connections than slick promotional videos.

People want to see the individuals behind the businesses they support.

What If Your Social Media Manager Works Remotely?

Not every business can accommodate regular on-site content capture, and that’s understandable.

A remote social media manager can still use stock B-roll, client-provided footage, or simple videos created by employees.

The important thing is having a plan for incorporating video rather than ignoring it entirely.

Don’t judge a candidate solely by their ability to produce highly polished videos. Ask how they’ll create authentic content that reflects your business.

7. Expecting Results Too Quickly

Social media marketing is a long-term investment in visibility, credibility, and relationships.

One mistake business owners make is expecting significant results after only a few weeks.

In my experience, you should allow approximately six months to see meaningful traction from a well-executed organic social media strategy.

That doesn’t mean waiting six months before evaluating performance.

Your social media manager should provide regular reporting, monitor engagement, and make adjustments as needed.

But building a relevant, engaged audience takes consistency.

A few posts won’t accomplish what months of purposeful content can achieve.

8. Not Participating in the Content Creation Process

Hiring a social media manager doesn’t mean the business owner can completely disconnect from social media.

Someone inside the company needs to communicate what’s happening in the business.

What challenges are customers facing? Are there seasonal concerns? What makes your company different from competitors?

These details help create content that actually connects with your audience.

Your Employees Are Valuable Content Resources

A social media manager can create content without your team’s participation, but that limits what they can accomplish.

Videos featuring owners, employees, and real business activities help customers see the people behind the brand.

This is especially important for service businesses where trust influences purchasing decisions.

The research needed to create a strong social media strategy is never truly finished. Your business and customers are constantly evolving.

Monthly meetings are a good opportunity to discuss changes in the market, customer questions, and upcoming opportunities.

For a broader understanding of how strategy, content, and engagement work together, explore our complete guide to social media marketing.

9. Not Establishing Clear Communication and Approval Processes

Another mistake is failing to establish expectations for content reviews, approvals, and communication.

Some business owners want to approve every post. Others become comfortable allowing their social media manager to publish without individual approval after building trust.

Neither approach is wrong, but expectations need to be clear.

Ask how far in advance content will be submitted, how feedback should be provided, and what happens if you don’t respond before a deadline.

For example, if your agreement states that content will be published automatically unless you request changes within two business days, make sure you understand and approve that process.

Businesses in regulated industries may require formal approval of every post.

Clear procedures protect both the business and the social media manager.

10. Not Considering Whether the Strategy Fits Your Business

A strategy that works for a boutique or restaurant may not work for a law firm, accounting practice, or home services company.

Different businesses have different audiences, customer behaviors, and marketing objectives.

Your social media manager should understand those differences before recommending platforms, posting frequency, or content types.

Don’t assume your business needs to be active everywhere.

Understanding which social media platforms are best for your business can help you focus your resources where your ideal customers are most likely to engage.

A qualified manager should be able to explain why they’re recommending a particular approach rather than simply offering the same package to every business.

How to Avoid These Social Media Hiring Mistakes

The best way to avoid hiring the wrong social media manager is to understand what the job actually involves.

Don’t be persuaded by a large personal following, promises of viral content, or an unusually low monthly fee.

Instead, look for someone who:

  • Has genuine marketing experience
  • Takes time to understand your business
  • Develops a strategy before creating content
  • Prioritizes authentic content and video
  • Understands the importance of building trust and community
  • Communicates regularly and reports on results
  • Sets realistic expectations


At The Seedless Agency, we believe social media should be treated as a meaningful part of your marketing strategy, not simply another task to check off a list. Our organic social media management services are built around that philosophy, combining strategy, consistent content creation, and audience engagement to help businesses build meaningful connections with their customers.

The right social media manager doesn’t just know how to post. They know how to make your business worth following.

If you’re ready to start the hiring process, Indeed offers a helpful guide to hiring a social media manager that covers the practical steps of finding and evaluating candidates. Just remember that beyond qualifications and deliverables, you’re looking for someone who understands how to turn social media into a valuable long-term marketing asset.

WELCOME!

Are you here to browse, or do you just want to skip to the part where we help grow your business?

Fill out the form and we’ll get back to you faster than your last agency replied to an email.